When did this happen in marketing? For the last few years we have seen the political preemptive strike has become common and overused.
EXAMPLE “All (Only) Reasonable economists say what we did was effective”
This type of statement has no place in marketing. It is negative and separates rather than drawing in. Marketers associate the things we strive to achieve with their product, babies and puppy dogs right! In the 1990s the cultural bubble was self-help books and we started to see marketers slipping that garbage into messaging that failed and even killed some good products.
If today’s cultural bubble is politics and that is your thing great. While I personally think this is more dangerous than self- help books marketers need to protect from any similar speech in their messaging. Segmentation teaches us that more today than ever the market is a rich matrix of individuals who belong to many tribes. To insert judgmental or eliminating terms can separate market share from your product.
Geoffrey Moore famously wrote about the positioning unlike statement. That focus was to define your product as part of product group.
EXAMPLE “Unlike many whole grain breads, Our product does not use whole lumber fillers”
Think about the difference of these two examples. Use the later not the former, the first is negative the latter definitive.